Important European decisions concerning public safety in the digital environment

The European Commission preliminarily found both TikTok and Meta in breach of their obligation to grant researchers adequate access to public data under the Digital Services Act (DSA). The Commission also preliminarily found Meta, for both Instagram and Facebook, violating its obligations to provide users simple mechanisms to notify illegal content, as well as to allow them to effectively challenge content moderation decisions.

The Commission’s preliminary findings show that Facebook, Instagram and TikTok may have put in place burdensome procedures and tools for researchers to request access to public data. This often leads to inadequate or unreliable data being delivered, impacting their ability to conduct research, such as whether users, including minors, are exposed to illegal or harmful content.

Allowing researchers access to platforms’ data is an essential transparency obligation under the DSA, as it allows the public to scrutinize the potential impact of platforms on people’s physical and mental health.

In addition, neither Facebook nor Instagram appear to provide a user-friendly and easily accessible ‘Notice and Action’ mechanism for users to flag illegal content, such as child sexual abuse material and terrorist content.  What is even more worrying is that both Facebook and Instagram probably use so-called ‘dark patterns’, or deceptive interface designs, when it comes to the ‘Notice and Action’ mechanisms.

Such practices can be confusing and dissuading and Meta’s mechanisms to flag and remove illegal content may therefore be ineffective. 

The Commission continues its investigation into other potential breaches that are part of these ongoing proceedings. The procedures under the DSA are distinct from ongoing investigations against Facebook, Instagram and TikTok concerning compliance with other relevant EU law.

Another dubious case pertains to Meta’s and Instagram’s usage of public user data to train its own artificial intelligence (AI) models since 27 May 2025. In this regard, the NRW (North Rhine-Westphalia) Consumer Rights Organisation (VZ NRW) raised data protection concerns and a claim for imposition of a temporary injunction.

The Higher Regional Court (OLG) of Cologne dismissed the application for the injunction under the reasoning which contains important points of reference for all companies that want to train an AI with the help of user or customer data.

Meta bases its AI training on its “legitimate interest”, namely the economic interest in developing and marketing a new AI product – more precisely, a conversation assistant.

The OLG’s decision offers opportunities for companies that want to train AI models with user data – and not just for social networks. In particular, the court has now established that AI training with user data can be a legitimate interest of companies due to the AI Act – the central regulation of AI in the EU – which itself refers to the need to train AI models with huge amounts of data.

At the same time, the judgement does not grant a “free pass” for AI training. Rather, the OLG emphasises that companies must formulate their legitimate interest “sufficiently clearly and precisely” and that this interest must be real. Furthermore, companies must demonstrate that it is necessary to process the personal data in order to fulfil the interest. There must therefore be no less intrusive, equally suitable alternatives to the use of user data. Meta, for example, was able to credibly demonstrate that it had examined alternatives, such as the use of synthetic data, but that these were not equally suitable.

In addition, the legitimate interest must be weighed against the interests of the data subjects. Meta has taken various measures here to ensure the protection of the data subjects.

The decision of the Higher Regional Court of Cologne shows the requirements of the GDPR must be carefully examined on a case-by-case basis.

Important European decisions concerning public safety in the digital environment

The European Commission preliminarily found both TikTok and Meta in breach of their obligation to grant researchers adequate access to public data under the Digital Services Act (DSA). The Commission also preliminarily found Meta, for both Instagram and Facebook, violating its obligations to provide users simple mechanisms to notify illegal content, as well as to allow them to effectively challenge content moderation decisions.

The Commission’s preliminary findings show that Facebook, Instagram and TikTok may have put in place burdensome procedures and tools for researchers to request access to public data. This often leads to inadequate or unreliable data being delivered, impacting their ability to conduct research, such as whether users, including minors, are exposed to illegal or harmful content.

Allowing researchers access to platforms’ data is an essential transparency obligation under the DSA, as it allows the public to scrutinize the potential impact of platforms on people’s physical and mental health.

In addition, neither Facebook nor Instagram appear to provide a user-friendly and easily accessible ‘Notice and Action’ mechanism for users to flag illegal content, such as child sexual abuse material and terrorist content.  What is even more worrying is that both Facebook and Instagram probably use so-called ‘dark patterns’, or deceptive interface designs, when it comes to the ‘Notice and Action’ mechanisms.

Such practices can be confusing and dissuading and Meta’s mechanisms to flag and remove illegal content may therefore be ineffective. 

The Commission continues its investigation into other potential breaches that are part of these ongoing proceedings. The procedures under the DSA are distinct from ongoing investigations against Facebook, Instagram and TikTok concerning compliance with other relevant EU law.

Another dubious case pertains to Meta’s and Instagram’s usage of public user data to train its own artificial intelligence (AI) models since 27 May 2025. In this regard, the NRW (North Rhine-Westphalia) Consumer Rights Organisation (VZ NRW) raised data protection concerns and a claim for imposition of a temporary injunction.

The Higher Regional Court (OLG) of Cologne dismissed the application for the injunction under the reasoning which contains important points of reference for all companies that want to train an AI with the help of user or customer data.

Meta bases its AI training on its “legitimate interest”, namely the economic interest in developing and marketing a new AI product – more precisely, a conversation assistant.

The OLG’s decision offers opportunities for companies that want to train AI models with user data – and not just for social networks. In particular, the court has now established that AI training with user data can be a legitimate interest of companies due to the AI Act – the central regulation of AI in the EU – which itself refers to the need to train AI models with huge amounts of data.

At the same time, the judgement does not grant a “free pass” for AI training. Rather, the OLG emphasises that companies must formulate their legitimate interest “sufficiently clearly and precisely” and that this interest must be real. Furthermore, companies must demonstrate that it is necessary to process the personal data in order to fulfil the interest. There must therefore be no less intrusive, equally suitable alternatives to the use of user data. Meta, for example, was able to credibly demonstrate that it had examined alternatives, such as the use of synthetic data, but that these were not equally suitable.

In addition, the legitimate interest must be weighed against the interests of the data subjects. Meta has taken various measures here to ensure the protection of the data subjects.

The decision of the Higher Regional Court of Cologne shows the requirements of the GDPR must be carefully examined on a case-by-case basis.